Red Government Fleet with star logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Can EVs Work as Patrol Vehicles?

Adding a fleet of battery-electric vehicles or plug-in hybrids to your motor pool is one thing. But giving an electrified sedan to a police officer seems like a trickier proposition.

Paul Clinton
Paul ClintonSenior Web Editor
Read Paul's Posts
December 8, 2016
3 min to read


Photo by Thi Dao

Sustainability initiatives touted by elected leaders, especially mayors during big-city election cycles, have brought electrified vehicles to the front burner for public fleet managers, despite persistently low fuel prices.

Adding greener vehicles to municipal fleets carries a weighty environmental message to voters, and it's a responsible step toward lessening air pollution and reliance on petroleum-based fuels. Adding a fleet of battery-electric vehicles or plug-in hybrids to your motor pool is one thing. Helping administrators reach a weekly meeting across town makes good sense.

But giving an electrified sedan to a police officer seems like a trickier proposition. Big-city officers push vehicles to the limit during duty cycles with high-speed driving, aggressive cornering, and excessive idling during investigations. When you talk to them, they often prefer gasoline-powered sedans tuned for dynamic driving and power when they mash the accelerator.

In June, the City of Los Angeles purchased 100 BMW i3 hatchbacks for civilian employees for meetings or site visits and sworn officers on routine assignments. Earlier in the year, the LAPD began testing two Tesla Model S sedans and in October, the agency's fleet manager said the agency would test a Model S as a patrol car.

The agency views the Model S as a viable option because if offers higher performance and a longer range than any other EVs on the market. However, the vehicle costs more than three times that of a traditional patrol vehicle at more than $83,000.

At first blush, spending nearly $100,000 for a patrol vehicle seems financially reckless, but some fleet managers say the total cost of ownership calculation favors the Tesla.

David Worthington, the County of Sonoma's fleet manager, has analyzed the total cost of ownership (TCO) of a Model S versus a traditional sedan. He found that the reduced maintenance and fuel costs of the Tesla would keep it in service for twice as long (180,000 miles versus 90,000 miles). He would go through two traditional police vehicles in the time he had the Tesla in service.

"We internally equip and set up patrol vehicles for our sheriff's office and six other cities and agencies and have been doing so for more than 20 years," Worthington said. "Our technical team is very skilled and adept at overcoming all of the challenges that a new vehicle presents to be used in a variety of assignments and duty cycles. The assistance we need from vehicle manufacturers is mainly around supplemental restraint systems, air bag deployment zones, and electrical wiring diagrams. We have been seeking a contact within Telsa that can provide us with an engineer that can answer our questions and provide us with basic information to ensure that the driver, occupants and our team members that are setting up the vehicles are safe."

Other municipal and county fleets on the West Coast are also looking at EVs for patrol use. Doug Bond, the transportation services manager with the County of Alameda, has had conversations with Tesla about using a Model S for patrol.

"We would be very interested," Bond said. "The challenge is the ability of the vehicle to store enough power to make it through a duty cycle. The other issue is the ability to continue past the standard duty cycle to address an emergency situation."

How the vehicle would perform during a high-speed pursuit is a question that still must be answered. But a Model S seems to meet some of Bond's criteria.

"I do feel that a Tesla model would address these concerns," Bond said. "In our conversations with Tesla, they are willing to sell us cars, but we would be interested in engaging in conversations about branding a Tesla as a patrol car."

As public fleet managers consider more efficient ways to manage their vehicles, EVs must be considered, and even used, for patrol and other assignments that may seem counterintuitive. Just like any other fleet vehicle purchase, it will require calculation of costs, input from affected stakeholders, and buy-in from vendors.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

Managing a Police Fleetby Roselynne ReyesNovember 27, 2019

The Future of Police Fleets? Dubai Police Teases Cybertruck for Patrol

The Dubai Police Department posted a mockup of Tesla's new Cybertruck fitted with patrol-ready vehicle graphics.

Read More →

How Chevrolet's Tahoe PPV Differs From its Retail Relative

For the Chevrolet Tahoe PPV, tires are added to the vehicles that are capable of handling speeds of up to 134 mph and the brakes are adjusted to handle frequent stopping at high speeds.

Read More →
Managing a Police Fleetby Paul ClintonNovember 1, 2017

Police Vehicles Pushed to the Limit in California

The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department conducted its annual evaluation of 2018-model-year police vehicles from Oct. 10 to 13. Agency deputies got behind the wheel of 13 four-wheel vehicles and five motorcycles for the testing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managing a Police Fleetby Paul ClintonOctober 5, 2017

2018 Police Motorcycles Tested in Michigan

Harley-Davidson adds performance-oriented stage kits to its pair of bikes, while Yamaha offers a police version of its FJR1300 sport touring model.

Read More →
Managing a Police Fleetby Staff WriterOctober 3, 2017

2018 Police Vehicles Tested in Michigan

Michigan State Police test Ford's F-150 and hybrid sedan responders, as well as a Dodge Durango, during a 2018-model-year testing round that broadened the options for pursuit vehicles.

Read More →
Managing a Police Fleetby Paul ClintonSeptember 1, 2017

The Efficiency of the CHP's Vehicle Assembly Line

The California Highway Patrol uses an assembly line similar to one found in an automaker's factory to add auxiliary equipment to about 1,000 vehicles per year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Managing a Police Fleetby Paul ClintonAugust 17, 2017

How FCA Views the Police Market

Law enforcement agencies continue to purchase Fiat Chrysler's Dodge Charger Pursuit, which appeals to law enforcement officers, who say the vehicle in a violator's rear-view conveys business.

Read More →

Upgrading the F-150 for Off-Road Patrol

Ford took the wraps off its 2018 F-150 Police Responder earlier this month and showed police agencies its latest tool for law enforcement work on more rugged terrain. Early feedback indicates that the truck will find a place with more rural agencies.

Read More →
Managing a Police Fleetby Patrick Oliver and Samuel KirchhoffJune 28, 2017

Managing High-Speed Pursuits

Pursuits can be deadly for everyone involved, but they can't be prohibited in all cases. So agencies need to have policies and procedures in place to reduce the danger.

Read More →
Ad Loading...

How to Deal With the Privileges of Rank

In law enforcement, police chiefs, sheriffs, and other top brass have been known to request higher trim grades and other vehicle upgrades, which can present challenges to the public fleet manager who must repurpose the vehicle after the chief switches into a new vehicle.

Read More →