Containing and reducing fleet costs continues to be a key challenge to many government fleet managers. In August 2005, the city of Portland, Ore. — the self-described birthplace of U.S. carsharing — implemented a carsharing pilot program for its motor pool fleet.
The program is expected to save the city approximately $30,000, or 25 percent, of the current motor pool’s annual operating, maintenance, and fuel costs.
Bruce Cross, now-retired fleet manager for CityFleet, the city of Portland’s fleet division, helped kick off the pilot program with Flexcar, a provider of carsharing vehicles. The city has about 2,600 vehicles representing light-duty vans, sedans, and pickups, in addition to heavy equipment.
Previously, CityFleet kept 25 central motor pool vehicles available to city employees. That number has been reduced to 13 during the transition to the carsharing program.
Lowering Costs without Sacrificing Mobility
During the pilot program, city employees reserve Flexcar vehicles online and pick up the cars at a number of locations in downtown Portland via a smart card. Trips are billed by the hour, with gas and insurance included in the cost of the trip.
“The program’s intent is to lower the city’s operational costs for the short-term transportation needs of city employees, without sacrificing service,” said Cross.
Employees register individually with Flexcar, and each bureau is billed directly for the use. About 80 carshare vehicles are located in downtown Portland, available on a first-come first-serve basis. About half of the available vehicles are gas-electric hybrids, mostly Honda Civics.
“Overall, drivers have expressed mostly positive feedback about the carsharing program,” said Cross. The benefits for employees who are also individual members of the Flexcar program include a large savings on the expense of car ownership, such as purchase, maintenance, operating costs, insurance, and parking. It also allows for carshare members to use lower emission vehicles.
The city benefits as well. “The carsharing program allows us to reduce an asset of approximately $150,000 in motor pool value, eliminate the need for capital expenses to upgrade software and key management systems, and increase the opportunity for employees to use more emissions-friendly vehicles and choose alternative-fuel vehicles,” said Cross.
A review of the pilot program is expected throughout the first year to fully determine its effectiveness and cost savings.
Portland Outsources Motor Pool without Sacrificing Mobility
Outsourcing the motor pool fleet is expected to save the city of Portland $30,000 each year in operating costs, maintenance, and fuel costs. Hybrids comprise half the carsharing vehicles being utilized.
More Operations

Is Fleet in a Reset Mode? | GovCast Shorts
On the go and want a snapshot of our top industry news? Check out Government Fleet's new video short of what's been happening.
Read More →
Are You Paid Enough? Fleet Salary Study Open
Work Truck, Automotive Fleet, and Government Fleet have partnered to conduct a salary survey to determine the average salary for a fleet management position in commercial and public sector fleets.
Read More →
Hybrids: Electrification Without the Challenges
Hybrids bridge the gap between ICE vehicles and EVs, making them a smart choice for fleets that want to reduce emissions but aren’t ready to fully electrify. Hybrids, which are powered by internal combustion engines and electric motors, capture the benefits of electric power without the barriers many organizations find challenging.
Read More →
Fleet Performance Comes Down to People, Data, and Budgets
When it comes to the public sector, outcomes are usually driven by three areas fleet leaders can actually control, but it’s combining these into one operating model where operations see the most success.
Read More →
Why One Car Wash Wasn’t Enough For This Fleet
Limited wash locations can increase travel time, fuel costs, and admin work for fleets. Here’s how one government fleet expanded access and simplified operations.
Read More →
Leading Fleets Lessons, Autonomous Policing, and the BEV Reality Check | The January Dispatch
To keep you in the loop, this episode is a quick reset on what mattered during the past month, from how to turn award season into a practical self-audit to what “leadership” looks like.
Read More →
Bobit Business Media Launches New Rewards Program for Industry Professionals
The new rewards initiative, B2X Rewards, is a gamified incentive program designed to increase engagement across BBM’s websites, eNewsletters, events, and TheFleetSource.com.
Read More →
Cold Weather, EV Reality Checks, and What Fleet Leaders Are Doing Next | GovCast Shorts
On the go and want a snapshot of our top industry news? Check out Government Fleet's new video short of what's been happening.
Read More →
Your Leading Fleets Application Can Do More Than Win an Award
Hear directly from this year's judges on what separates standout submissions and use their tips to submit a clearer, stronger application.
Read More →
City of Alexandria's DASH Partners with ABM to Support EV Bus Charging Infrastructure
DASH is expanding its electric bus operations in Alexandria, Va., with new in-route charging infrastructure.
Read More →
