Red Government Fleet with star logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

From Good to Great: The Value of Culture in Fleet Management

Looking at the trend between truly great fleets and those that barely survive and how this centers around the clarity of fleet culture.

August 23, 2024
From Good to Great: The Value of Culture in Fleet Management

Purpose, values, and mission form the bedrock of truly great fleets; they are the foundation of an organization's culture.

Photo: Government Fleet

5 min to read


Have you ever been stung by surprise when a top employee quits? Have you ever found it difficult to pinpoint exactly why you think one job candidate is a good fit or why you should run like hell from another?

Does your team feel like they are running around with their hair on fire, or are they in reactive mode instead of proactive mode? Could your team tell you what makes your fleet unique or why they stay instead of running down the road where the pay is significantly better?

Over the years, as the CEO of RTA, I've visited hundreds of fleets, asking these same questions. I've seen an interesting trend between the truly great fleets and those that barely survive. It's the same trend that author Jim Collins found in his research of great businesses. It centers around the clarity of your culture.

Recognizing the Importance of Culture

Over the next few articles, we'll dive into the foundations of what makes a great culture (and spoiler: it's not just monthly BBQ in the breakroom). When done right, you'll be well on your way to being a leading fleet leader with happier team members and less stress in your day-to-day life.

For those unfamiliar with Collins' work, he's the bestselling author of books like "Good to Great" and "Built to Last," where he and his team examine dozens of different companies to figure out what separates the outstanding companies from the run-of-the-mill mediocre ones.

One of the most fascinating things he found in his comparisons was that the great companies were all fanatical about their organizational DNA. They were crystal clear about why they were doing what they were doing. They were committed to living by a set of principles or behaviors, something he labeled as core values. And they all had compelling goals and missions.

Understanding Your Fleet’s Purpose, Values, and Mission

These three things (purpose, values, and mission) form the bedrock of truly great fleets; they are the foundation of an organization's culture. As you reflect on your fleet, are you crystal clear on these things? Is your team?

Could I walk out onto your shop floor and ask your newest tech what your core values or mission are? Is everyone held to the same standards around those core values? If I looked at your hiring process, would I see you refer to your purpose and values frequently?

Do you willingly turn down candidates who don't fit the mold? Even in the face of a technician shortage?

Most fleets I walk into aren't clear on their purpose, values, and mission; several haven't even heard of them.

What's been evident to me for many years is that while Jim Collins may be common reading in the business world, most of us in fleet haven't heard of him or his research. We haven't been exposed to the work of others, like Patrick Lencioni, who focuses on eliminating team dysfunction and creating healthy organizations.

We aren't given leadership lessons on how to inspire, motivate, or coach our teams from Navy SEALs like Jocko Willink or Leif Babin, authors of "Extreme Ownership." We've never been taught how to strategize or set goals from the likes of Netflix, Amazon, or Google.

Becoming a Better Leader for Your Team

I was teaching about "The Five Dysfunctions of a Team" at our user event several years ago, and the fleet manager from one of the fastest growing municipalities in the U.S. came up, emotionally moved, in gratitude, because no one had ever taken the time to teach her about this. She'd never been to a leadership seminar and was never taught how to coach others.

She said that higher-ups get this type of education, but never us in fleet.

And it was true. I would rarely see fleet leaders get that level of investment. We could only lead based on what was modeled before us, especially those of us who came from the ground up.

It set me on a mission to help individuals in fleet leadership positions to become better leaders. That starts by building a culture they can be proud of—a culture that employees love, which helps them find joy and fulfillment at work so they can be better people at home.

As leaders, we have a tremendous duty to be stewards of those in our care. Do you recognize the impact you can have on your team members' lives? Imagine building a culture so amazing that when your employees go home at the end of the day, they still have energy and excitement to see their kids instead of being miserable and beaten down by the grind. Do you know the difference you can make for your team's families and loved ones and how far-reaching your leadership goes?

If we want to build an incredible culture like that, it starts with us as leaders being intentional and creating clarity around purpose, values, and mission, as Jim Collins wrote about in Built to Last. Of course, that's just the beginning, and it's not easy. You then must reinforce that clarity and fight for it every day.

There's no magic formula for overnight success. But, as someone who has done that work and gone through that transformation, I cannot say it loudly enough: it is so worth it. We have all seen that attracting and retaining good fleet talent is difficult, and pay is often a tough incentive for fleets. Getting your culture right is critical and will likely be the secret to your fleet's success, so get ready to transform your fleet!

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

Fleet Voicesby Staff WriterNovember 20, 2025

How Electric Vehicles as a Service Could Reshape Public Fleets

How the EV model can address concerns about meeting state mandates, cost, emissions and range anxiety.

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Rachael PlantNovember 19, 2025

14 Metrics Government Fleets Should Track

The metrics government fleets should track to get a full understanding of their fleet operation.

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Facundo TassaraNovember 12, 2025

Pick One: Hire a Technician or a Data Analyst

Short on techs and drowning in data, which single hire moves your fleet farther—a technician or a data analyst—and how does AI change the calculus?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Fleet Voicesby James "Jimmy" JohnstonNovember 10, 2025

Why Refuse Truck Tech Must Serve the Operator

Ride along on a pre-dawn refuse route to see how operator-first, integrated safety technology turns split-second risk into preventable events and why purpose-built trucks are the next step in fleet safety.

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Rachael PlantOctober 31, 2025

7 Tips for Smarter Fleet Management

The potential to manage your fleet effectively while ensuring the safety of both employees and the community can often go untapped, but there are certain habits you can adopt to get to that point.

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Jason AlbericiOctober 3, 2025

Why Benefits Are Key for State and Local Fleets Looking to Win Federal Talent

State and local agencies have a unique chance to recruit skilled federal employees affected by workforce changes, but doing so will require strengthening total rewards packages with competitive benefits and financial wellness support.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Fleet Voicesby Mike ClearySeptember 23, 2025

Diagnostic Strategies, Industry Insights, and More: Tech Corner Begins

Industry veteran Mike Cleary shares his journey in automotive and truck diagnostics while setting the stage for future insights, tips, and strategies aimed at helping fleet professionals sharpen their technical and diagnostic skills.

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Nick LeeSeptember 19, 2025

Succession Planning for Public Fleet Leaders

As fleet leaders approach retirement, one critical question looms: Who will take the wheel when they step aside?

Read More →
Fleet Voicesby Rachael PlantSeptember 2, 2025

A Complete Guide to Being a Fleet Manager [Part 2]

Fleet managers are the ones who coordinate keeping fleet assets safe and running while staying apprised of industry challenges that could impact staffing, uptime, costs, routing, etc. But the key question is: How?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Fleet Voicesby Peyton WinsteadJuly 16, 2025

Getting Started with Vehicle-to-Everything Tech: Use Cases to Maximize Benefits

Tools like V2X technology can help address current fleet issues , it can also be difficult to find real-world examples of how to actually do it.

Read More →